The good and bad side of corporal punishment

That power-assertive methods are not as effective as inductive discipline in promoting moral internalisation has been shown in many studies.

Corporal punishment: good or bad?

Montaigne I believe in Corporal Punishment. Also remember that school is for learning and it is the teachers job if the students are doing poorly. Abuse is targeted at a certain group, and many times are strategically planned out.

Just like a father cannot be a mother to his kids neither can you expect a mother to be a father to her kids. How can you refute that the abolition of corporal punishment has not led to an increase in crime because of varying factors when the case that you cite to support your argument is so biased and overlooks a large number of factors- such as poverty, drop outs, consistent use of paddling, perceived fairness of paddling, credible or qualified teachers, etc.

However, if that has not been dealt with, then it becomes a habit, and in the real world, they would be incarcerated for making false statements. Most weekends she was called to the police station to deal with girls caught shoplifting and boys arrested for assault or vandalism.

The State of Research on the Effects of Physical Punishment

Gershoff a carried out a meta-analysis of 92 studies on corporal punishment, which examined the effect of punishment on 11 outcome variables.

A recent study tested the hypothesis that in cultures where physical punishment is normative, the effects of it are less negative Lansford et al.

Corporal Punishment Should Be Reintroduced

A woman cannot realistically be both mother and father no matter how hard she may try. Here are some articles describing her findings: Nonetheless, her research was not meant to serve as a green light for parents to spank their children, but rather a red light for those groups who want corporal punishment banned.

Corporal punishment does not actually administer a direct cause-and-effect link between a behaviour and its bad consequences. Power-assertive disciplinary techniques do not support moral internalisation.

Corporal punishment: good or bad?

Breaking a rule at school resulted in corporal punishment being administered. The amount of countries that do or do not have corporal punishment out lawed has no bearing on this debate.

Corporal punishment does not actually administer a direct cause-and-effect link between a behaviour and its bad consequences. About two-thirds of the children in the sample were insecurely attached, a figure about twice as high as would be expected from the general population.

There is need to encourage non-violent and non-humiliating ways of instilling discipline in them. I found several studies that has shown Corporal Punishment does more bad than good, but you did not show any opposing research. For example, if a correlation is found between physical punishment and child aggression, it may be that physical punishment leads to child aggression.

The study also included a measure of negative mother—child interactions. If we have a student that is about to become a school shooter, a few smacks is not going to stop them. Corporal punishment was associated with only one desirable behaviour, namely, increased immediate compliance.

One is physical and the other is mental. Thus, poorer cognitive outcomes may result if parents who physically punish their children make less use of inductive methods of discipline, such as explanation and reasoning — procedures that are likely to enhance cognitive growth.

Heavy punishment drives young people away from misbehaving and therefore would shape their future actions. But how do we reconcile these contradictory findings. There are many things that have changed and the rise in crime is a combination of some or maybe even all of these factors, things like increase in population, increasing living expectations, the poor and the rich living in a close proximity.

It is just as likely that it will create an unwanted association with the presence of the one administering the punishment e. The authors concluded that parental harshness was associated with poorer cognitive achievement and social adjustment in the school setting.

It was more of a deterrent for girls than it was for boys who were always challenging authority and getting into mischief. Besides a good and effective teacher is not going to use corporal punishment all the time, but as a last resort when all else fails.

That is a great idea. Research findings support ongoing efforts to help parents use more positive methods of parenting, and the removal of a defence in law for the use of physical punishment against children. Yet have any of these countries provided effective supports to parents in helping them discipline and punish out-of-control children.

The headmistress caned or slippered boys and girls on the bottom. Actually, when teachers hit, it actually lets the child think that violence is okay and than they take it out on others.

Grogan-Kaylor used data from the most recent wave of data collection of the United States National Longitudinal Survey of Youth. WASHINGTON — Corporal punishment remains a widely used discipline technique in most American families, but it has also been a subject of controversy within the child development and psychological communities.

What Science Says About Using Physical Force To Punish A Child

In a large-scale meta-analysis of 88 studies, psychologist Elizabeth Thompson Gershoff. Side opposition proposes that the benefits of using corporal punishment will outweigh the cons greatly, and is in favour of using this form of punishment. Side opposition, again, does not see the correlation in between corporal punishment and doing better in school, because those two are separate things.

Corporal punishment does not guarantee a harmful effect, but the more that children experience corporal punishment and the more frequent and severe it is, the more they are at risk for problems like aggression and depression, regardless of their cultural background.

Corporal punishment may have long-term negative effects on children's intelligence Date: July 26, Source: University of Toronto Summary: Children in a school that uses corporal punishment. To discipline they used fear, little encouragement and often corporal punishment.

Permissive Parents were markedly less controlling, minimally demanding, freely granting of the child’s demands, uninvolved with the child, and benign toward the child’s impulses and actions.

A survey led by Murray A. Straus and Julie H. Stewart, called "Corporal Punishment by American Parents," reported that 94 percent of parents have spanked their child by age three or four, and 50 percent still spanked when the child was 13 years sgtraslochi.comd: Jun 17,

The good and bad side of corporal punishment
Rated 3/5 based on 70 review
Debate Topic: Does Corporal Punishment do more Bad than Good? |